• The online Community for people with spinal cord injury, their relatives and friends

  • The online Community for people with spinal cord injury, their relatives and friends

  • The online Community for people with spinal cord injury, their relatives and friends

  • The online Community for people with spinal cord injury, their relatives and friends

  • The online Community for people with spinal cord injury, their relatives and friends

Comparing the shoulder load using a wheelchair versus a handbike

Author of summary: Ursina Arnet (Swiss Paraplegic Research)
Original article: Arnet U, van Drongelen S, Scheel-Sailer A, van der Woude LH, Veeger DH. Shoulder load during synchronous handcycling and handrim wheelchair propulsion in persons with paraplegia. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine. 2012;44(3):222-8.
When using a handcycle, the load on the shoulder is less than when using a wheelchair. Therefore handcycling should be preferred to using the wheelchair for longer distances outside or when training.

What was the aim of this study?

On average, half of all people with spinal cord injury (SCI) are suffering from shoulder pain. Often it is unclear what exactly the reason is for the shoulder pain since it is influenced by various factors. The repetitive wheelchair propulsion movement is often named as one of the most frequent reasons for shoulder pain. Researchers therefore want to find out whether alternative forms of transport such as the handbike are more suitable to overcome longer distances. Since the study concentrated on situations of everyday life, the clip-on handbike was tested. This means of transportation consists of the person’s own wheelchair that is connected to an additional unit in front of the wheelchair to move around outside.

How did the researchers proceed?

Eight wheelchair users with paraplegia were invited to the movement laboratory of Swiss Paraplegic Research. On a treadmill they were using the wheelchair and the handbike on four performance levels reaching from easy everyday performance (25 watts) to a performance simulating an inclination of 4% (55 watts).
During the tests, the mode of propelling of the subjects was analysed:

  • The applied forces were measured with sensors inside the handles of the handbike and the handrim of the wheelchair. This shows clearly which means of transport requires more power.
  • The movement of arms, hands and upper body were recorded using reflective markers and then depicted three-dimensionally.

Figure 1: test setup

The results were combined in a mathematic model of the shoulder. This allowed calculating which force impacts the shoulder joint, i.e. with how much strength the humerus is pressing on the socket of the shoulder joint. Furthermore, it was analysed when which shoulder muscle is active and how much. Both these results reflect the load on the shoulder joint. This made it possible to compare the shoulder load when using a handbike compared to the shoulder load when using a wheelchair.

What did the researchers discover?

The results show that the shoulder load is higher when a wheelchair is used. The maximum joint force is twice as high when using a wheelchair compared with the handbike (see figure 2). The highest forces were measured in the middle of the propulsion phase when using the wheelchair, whereas the strongest forces when using the handbike were measured when lifting the crank. Also the average values of the forces measured throughout a complete cycle (one crank rotation on the handbike; propulsion and return phase on the wheelchair) are lower when using a handbike.

Figure 2: force on shoulder joint at a power of 55 watt

In addition to the joint forces, also the muscle forces are higher on the wheelchair. The biggest differences were determined for both the supraspinatus and infraspinatus muscles. These are both muscles of the rotator cuffs that are stabilizing the shoulder joint and thus protecting from injuries.

What do these findings mean?

Former studies have shown that strong and frequent forces on the shoulder joint can lead to injuries. Due to the short propulsion phase, the maximum forces when using a wheelchair are very high. Since the shoulder joint forces during the complete cycle are also higher than when using a handbike, there is a higher risk of shoulder injuries when using a wheelchair.
When using a wheelchair, the muscles of the rotator cuffs, which stabilize the shoulder joint, are more heavily used than when using the handbike. If the wheelchair is propelled for longer periods, the risk of overfatigue of these muscles is higher which may lower their ability to protect the shoulder joint optimally and make it prone to injury and pain.
The results of the study have shown that the handbike is not only more efficient but also that there is a smaller shoulder load. Therefore the handbike should be the preferred means of transportation for the outside and for training.

Who conducted and financed the study?

The study was carried out and financed by Swiss Paraplegic Research (Switzerland).

Arnet et al_2012_Shoulder load during synchronious handcycling in SCI_J Rehabil med_published paper.pdf

Comments (0)

There are no comments on this topic yet.
Be the first to comment!

Rate this post

Most Recent Answers
5250 odyssita
Explaining what life with a chronic disability is like
Hi cAro, all the best for your research! I am very curious to hear about the results once they are being published. Thank you for researching this...
6 odyssita 2018-05-02
5166 Wheelie
Good news for all who would like to try out the Scewo by themselves: according the Scewo constructors, the feedback on their invention was so...
5 Johannes 2018-03-12
Ask the Expert
Most Recent Answers
3 Dr._Hans_old 2015-07-20
3 Dr._Hans_old 2015-05-07

Most Recent Blog Posts
Wheelchair chefs: the success stories
Disabilities matter but ambition rules
lorenzo.deluigi 2020-07-22 In News
Make to Care, a competition promoting innovations
Which one of these four innovative projects convinces you the most?
kitwan 2020-07-02 In Society
Wheelchair users’ game of thorns
The fight for personal space, safety and independence
Most Read
Anatomy and physiology of respiration
Breathing is the most normal thing in the world for us. We hardly think about it, even though we breathe in and out about 20,000 times per day. We breathe more when we are active and exerting ourselves, and we breathe less when we are...
Social skills increase quality of life
Today strawberry yogurt is on Anna’s* grocery list. In front of the dairy section she notices that she cannot reach the yogurt sitting in a wheelchair. Many stressed people are rushing through the crowded store during rush hour and she does not...
Mobilisation / Transferring
What do I need to consider with regard to the shoulders? The shoulder is the most heavily-strained joint with regard to mobilisation – that applies to sitting up and transferring. It is therefore important to protect the shoulders whenever it is...

About the Community
Most Recent Topics
2020-07-16 In Latest
Free masks for high-risk patients with SCI
People with high-level tetraplegia, paraplegics of higher age and those with pre-existing health conditions are more susceptible to a severe development of COVID-19. For this reason, the European...
2020-07-03 In Latest
A COVID inspiration porn?
Over three months since the COVID-19 declared pandemic, many countries are still debating whether to make wearing face masks compulsory to help prevent the spread of the disease. Noam Gershony, an...
2020-06-08 In Latest
The world’s first MSc program in disability, design and innovation
Disability innovation is more than just a good idea. We’ve heard enough stories how disability innovations can go wrong with unrealistic expectations and insufficient market research. This needs to...


Swiss Paraplegic Research
Guido A. Zäch Strasse 4
6207 Nottwil

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
T 0800 727 236 (from Switzerland, free of charge)
T +41 41 939 65 55 (from other countries, charges apply)

Be part of the Community – sign up now!